“I'm Scared, Not Misbehaving”: Helping Children Feel Safe Before Expecting Cooperation
Understanding Anxiety in Children | Part 2
Sometimes, the child who is refusing to walk into the classroom isn't trying to be difficult.
Sometimes, the child who starts crying when it's time to leave the house isn't trying to delay the morning routine.
And sometimes, the child who screams, runs away, or falls to the floor when asked to try something new isn't simply refusing to listen.
Sometimes, that child is scared.
As parents, we often find ourselves caught between two important responsibilities. We want to be understanding and compassionate toward our children, but we also need to help them navigate everyday expectations.
We can't always avoid going to school, attending appointments, or participating in activities simply because something feels uncomfortable.
But we also can't expect children to develop confidence by ignoring their distress.
So how do we find the balance?
It starts with recognizing that feeling safe and learning to cooperate aren't competing goals. They're often connected.
When Big Feelings Become Big Behaviors
Think about the last time you felt genuinely overwhelmed.
Maybe you were running late, juggling multiple responsibilities, or dealing with something unexpected.
Even as adults, our ability to think clearly, communicate effectively, and respond patiently can become more difficult when we're under significant stress.
Now imagine experiencing those feelings without having the language or coping skills to explain what's happening.
For young children, anxiety can show up in ways that adults don't immediately recognize.
A child might become unusually quiet, cling to a parent, repeat the same question, refuse an activity, or become upset over a seemingly minor change.
Other children may cry, yell, push materials away, or attempt to leave the situation entirely.
These behaviors don't automatically mean a child is experiencing anxiety. There can be many reasons for behavioral challenges, including communication difficulties, sensory discomfort, frustration, or unmet needs.
But when anxiety is part of the picture, focusing exclusively on stopping the behavior may overlook what the child actually needs.
Why “You're Fine” Doesn't Always Help
Most parents have said it.
"You're okay."
"There's nothing to be scared of."
"It's not a big deal."
We say these things because we want to reassure our children.
And often, we genuinely know that the situation is safe.
But there's an important difference between knowing something is safe and feeling safe.
A child who is frightened of entering a new classroom may not feel reassured simply because an adult tells them there's nothing to worry about.
Their fear is still real, even when the situation itself isn't dangerous.
Instead of immediately dismissing the fear, we can acknowledge it.
"I can see that you're nervous."
"This is something new, and new things can feel scary."
"I'm here to help you figure it out."
Acknowledging a child's feelings doesn't mean agreeing that the situation is dangerous. It means recognizing their emotional experience.
And that recognition can make it easier to work together toward the next step.
Connection Before Expectations
Imagine a child standing outside the entrance to a preschool classroom.
The teacher is waiting. Other children are already inside. The morning routine has started.
But the child is holding tightly to their parent's hand and refusing to enter.
One approach might be to repeatedly tell the child to go inside, remind them that they're expected to attend school, or become increasingly firm when they don't move.
Another approach begins by recognizing the child's distress.
The parent might kneel beside them, speak calmly, and acknowledge that entering the classroom feels difficult.
Then, rather than expecting the child to immediately complete the entire transition, the adult can help identify a manageable next step.
Maybe the child walks to the doorway.
Maybe they greet the teacher while remaining beside their parent.
Maybe they enter with a familiar adult and a preferred activity waiting.
Over time, with consistent support and positive experiences, the child may become increasingly comfortable completing the transition.
The expectation hasn't necessarily disappeared.

But the way we help the child meet that expectation has changed.
And that difference matters.
Teaching Coping Skills Instead of Just Expecting Calm
One of the challenges with emotional regulation is that adults sometimes expect children to demonstrate skills they haven't yet learned.
We tell children to calm down.
We ask them to use their words.
We remind them to take a deep breath.
But what happens when a child doesn't know how to recognize what they're feeling, communicate their needs, or use a coping strategy independently?
Those skills need to be taught.
For some children, that might mean learning to say, "I need help."
For others, it might mean recognizing when a situation feels overwhelming and requesting a break.
Some children may benefit from practicing a breathing exercise, identifying a trusted adult, using a visual support, or learning how to approach unfamiliar situations one step at a time.
And importantly, these skills are often most effectively introduced when the child is calm and available for learning.
We wouldn't expect a child to learn how to swim for the first time while struggling in deep water.
Similarly, we shouldn't expect a child to master an unfamiliar coping strategy in the middle of an overwhelming emotional experience.
We teach, practice, support, and gradually build independence.
What Does This Look Like in ABA?
In Applied Behavior Analysis, we work to understand the relationship between behavior and the environment.
When a child is experiencing anxiety-related difficulties, this may involve identifying situations that are challenging, understanding patterns of avoidance, and teaching skills that help the child navigate those situations more successfully.
For example, a child who becomes distressed during transitions may benefit from visual schedules, predictable routines, and opportunities to practice small changes.
A child who struggles with unfamiliar activities may benefit from gradual introductions, choices, and reinforcement for manageable steps toward participation.
A child who becomes overwhelmed in a group setting may need support learning how to request assistance, communicate discomfort, or take an appropriate break.
These strategies should be individualized and responsive to the child's needs.
It's also important to recognize that not every uncomfortable situation should be pushed through.
Sometimes a child needs a break.
Sometimes the environment needs to be modified.
And sometimes the most appropriate next step is collaborating with a mental health professional who specializes in childhood anxiety.
ABA can support functional skills and participation, but it is not a substitute for appropriate mental health assessment or treatment when an anxiety disorder is suspected.
Supporting Without Avoiding Everything
Here's where things can become complicated.
When we see our children upset, our natural instinct is often to remove whatever is making them uncomfortable.
And sometimes, that's exactly what they need.
But when a situation is safe and developmentally appropriate, consistently avoiding it may unintentionally make it harder for a child to build confidence.
For example, if a child feels nervous about joining a group activity and is always excused from participating, they may never have the opportunity to discover that they can manage the experience with support.
On the other hand, forcing participation before the child has the skills or support to cope can increase distress.
The goal is to find a thoughtful middle ground.
We can acknowledge the anxiety while helping children take manageable steps forward.
We can offer support without immediately removing every expectation.
And we can respect a child's communication while teaching them that difficult feelings don't always have to stop them from doing something meaningful.
Being supportive doesn't mean eliminating every challenge. It means helping children develop the skills to face challenges without feeling alone.
What Children Remember
Years from now, our children probably won't remember every morning routine, classroom transition, or difficult moment we helped them navigate.
But the experiences they have during those moments can shape how they approach challenges in the future.
They can learn that asking for help is okay.
That feeling nervous doesn't mean they're incapable.
That mistakes and uncomfortable feelings are part of learning.
And that the adults in their lives will listen, support them, and help them find a way forward.
We don't need to eliminate every difficult feeling from childhood.
We need to help children understand those feelings, communicate their needs, and gradually develop the confidence to navigate the world around them.
Because sometimes, the child who appears to be refusing isn't asking us to lower every expectation.
They're asking us to recognize that something feels hard.
And when we respond with understanding, patience, and meaningful support, we give them something far more valuable than immediate cooperation.
We give them the opportunity to feel understood while learning that they are capable of doing hard things.
This article is Part 2 of Thrive Pediatric Behavioral Health's Understanding Anxiety in Children series, exploring the relationship between anxiety, emotional safety, behavior, and the development of coping skills.
Thrive Pediatric Behavioral Health
Compassionate, individualized behavioral support for children and families.





Comments